The Playbook That Stopped Working

The Playbook That Stopped Working

June 30, 20267 min read

TLDR;

Most senior change and transformation leaders are running on a toolkit that built their reputation across the last decade and is no longer doing what it used to. The signs are subtle. The work runs harder than it should. Stakeholders are harder to move. The frameworks get nods, not action. The cost is rarely visible inside any one project. It compounds across them. In this piece, I name what is actually happening, why nobody will tell you, and what an upgraded craft makes possible.

🎧 If you prefer to listen to this edition instead, check out the link below to an audio podcast as a deep dive which is AI-generated based on this edition and Jess' intellectual property:

https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fo/ah1wqtt8u9kgvlchtwlvq/AAWXvIuDKzYsUAQRTY7Ik-E/Why_your_leadership_playbook_stopped_working.m4a?rlkey=yn3t56cddkcmmw0ote81225tk&st=xnb4kwgc&dl=0

The signal nobody will give you

You can feel it before you can name it. The work is taking longer than it should. The stakeholders are harder to move than they used to be. The frameworks used to land are getting nods rather than action. The toolkit that built your reputation over the last decade is still the one you use, but it is no longer doing what it used to.


Nobody will give you this signal directly. Your team will not. Your sponsor will not. The market will not tell you in a single moment. The market tells you in a slow accumulation of small misses across months, and by the time the pattern is clear, you are already months behind.

What is it costing you, without you naming it

The cost of running on an outdated toolkit is never visible inside any one project. It compounds across them.


Each transformation runs slightly harder than it should. Each stakeholder takes slightly longer to move. Each result lands slightly less clearly. There is talk behind your back that you don’t like. Decisions made without you, and things magically bypass you. Each report requires slightly more polish to mask the gap between the methodology and the work. None of it is dramatic in isolation. All of it adds up.


The shape of the cost is also financial and quietly material. The day rate that should be moving up is not. The senior conversations you should be having are not finding you. The premium client work that should be your next chapter is going to someone whose craft moved on while yours held still.


There is also a personal cost that is harder to name. The fulfilment that used to come from doing the work well starts to thin. The energy required to deliver the same outcome becomes more. The work feels like an activity rather than having an impact. And the slow ache of working harder for less starts to settle in, in a way that does not show up in any review or scorecard.

Why does the audit feel uncomfortable?

The audit you would need to run on your own craft is harder than it sounds.

The toolkit you built your career on is harder to question the longer you have relied on it. There is identity wrapped up in it. A deep-seated mindset. There is success wrapped up in it. There is muscle memory. There is the reasonable position: "This is what worked, why would I question it?"

The answer is that the work you are doing now is not the work you were doing five years ago.

And before this sounds like … “Well, of course.. Dah..” hold on! I know you see how different things are mostly in pace and intensity. But I am walking about your ways of dealing with this and more… Stakeholders' nervous systems are wired and tired! The practices are linear (even if you call them agile); they are still stacking up in a way that the organisation can't accommodate much. The runway is shorter, so you need to articulate differently and be direct; being 2-3 steps ahead is becoming a necessity; waiting for permission and validation is a setback; not being attuned to what is urgent and worrying becomes your asset….

Organisations are more complex. Sponsors' expectations have risen by two levels over the last 3 years. Cultures are harder to shift. Stakeholders are sharper, more sceptical, and more digitally fluent than the toolkits assume. AI is restructuring the discipline in real time. Commercial outcomes are no longer optional. Project artefacts no longer satisfy.

The leaders who deliver change or transformation now are being asked to operate across functions and industries in ways the older toolkits never required.

The reframe that actually opens something

The most important thing to understand is that you are not behind. You are due.


Due for an upgrade of the craft itself. Not more frameworks, or more theory, and certainly not another certification stacked on top of the ones you already have. A sharpening of the actual craft.

The way you read systems.

The way you read stakeholders.

The way you sell the change.

The way you shift the culture.

The way you apply critical thinking when the pressure is on.

The way you draw lessons from across industries, because no single industry has the answer to what is in front of you anymore.


A current craft today is multidisciplinary. It reads between the lines. It connects dots that other practitioners miss. It stays sharp enough to be useful in the room, not just useful in the report.


When it is current, the work creates cut-through. The transformation actually transforms rather than just being delivered. The leadership elevates, and the impact stays. And for you, the fulfilment that comes from doing the work well, instead of just doing more of it, returns.

What this looks like in real terms from our members

Michelle, a Global Change & Transformation Leader, described what a sharpened craft looks like once it lands:


"Dr Jess Tayel is a brilliant and revolutionary transformation, change and leadership mentor and coach. Through her programs, she not only teaches best practices in designing Transformation Programs but also in working with and thriving in Complex Environments and Cultures. She can help you to become people-centric, working with empathy and high emotional intelligence, to deliver business-critical and strategic Transformation & Change Programs that deliver tangible value and outcomes. This is what truly stands out in Jess's approach. It is the future of how Transformation should be run."


Doug, Solution Design Manager in Supply Chain at DHL, said it in fewer words:


"Jess is an exceptional coach whose knowledge goes well beyond surface level. If you want to get to that next level of understanding of what good truly looks like when it comes to transformation and change, and also take your knowledge to that next level in a way that you can directly apply, then working with Jess is a must."


Michael, Senior Consultant in Transformation & Governance, named the multidisciplinary shift:


"TLI has been an enriching experience for me: sharpening my ability to ask better questions, uncover complex system dynamics, and focus effort where it delivers lasting leverage. I appreciated the opportunity to cultivate a multi-disciplinary mindset by learning from experts across a range of industries. The insights I gained through TLI, Jess, and our generous community will continue to shape my transformation and change practice going forward."


3 different roles with 3 different vantage points, all with the same pattern.

Upgrading your practice today

The above should give you enough to assess the signs and maybe have an honest conversation with yourself about what it means for you. Because, personally, I see it everywhere, and I do get a lot of exposure to change and transformation practices in many countries and companies, and the patterns are obvious. Inside the framework I have built across twenty-five years of transformation work, this is the Practice pillar. Practice means your craft, your methods, the actual toolkit you deploy. Not theory. The thing you do.


The framework is called the Go To Leader (GTL) Model, and Elevate is where senior change and transformation professionals sharpen their craft. See the GTL Model below


📍Want to assess where you stand across the pillars that make up the Go To Leader GTL in your space? Here is the scorecard. Spend 10 minutes, and get a personalised report

https://www.futurefitleader.com/relevance-quiz

GTL Model

GTL Roadmap

It is not an aspiration or theory; there is a clear and structured roadmap

📍If something in this piece landed, the video showcase is here:
www.transformationleadership.institute/elevate-video-showcase


📍And Elevate is here:
www.transformationleadershipinstitute.com/elevate

Back to Blog

Meet The Author

Jess Tayel

Transformation Leadership & Strategy Execution Expert

Jess is an award-winning transformation strategist dedicated to equipping future-fit leaders to elevate their impact, leadership, and career. With over 25 years of global experience, she helps organizations and teams turn complexity into clarity and deliver change that sticks. Recognized as a top voice in transformation, she’s known for taking leaders and programs to the next level.

Topics

Follow For Updates

Stay connected with news and updates!